Mortgage Comparison Calculator
Put two Loan Estimates side by side over the years you expect to keep the loan, and see which one really costs less.
Free both options at your chosen horizon, the winner and the crossover point. Premium the year-by-year net cost of each option for the whole term.
Shared details
Over 7 years
| Item | Option A | Option B |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly principal and interest | $2,334.95 | $2,245.93 |
| Upfront cost (points + fees − credits) | $1,500.00 | $6,000.00 |
| Monthly payments made | $196,135.80 | $188,658.12 |
| Total cash out | $197,635.80 | $194,658.12 |
| Interest paid | $162,971.04 | $153,473.11 |
| Balance still owed | $326,835.24 | $324,814.99 |
| Net cost | $164,471.04 | $159,473.11 |
Option B costs $4,997.93 less over 7 years. The option with higher upfront cost becomes the cheaper one after 3 years 4 months.
Net cost = total cash out + balance still owed − loan amount: what the loan has cost you by then if you paid it off. It ignores taxes, investment returns on cash and inflation.
Year-by-year net cost
PremiumHow the Compare two loans calculator works
What it measures
It compares two loan offers for the same amount over the number of years you expect to keep the loan. For each it adds up the upfront cost, every monthly payment and the balance still owed at that point, so a cheaper-looking rate with more fees and a higher rate with credits can be judged fairly.
The inputs
- Loan amount and compare over: the same amount and horizon for both options.
- Interest rate and term for each option.
- Discount points: prepaid interest. One point costs 1% of the loan and usually lowers the rate.
- Lender credit: money the lender gives toward closing costs, usually for a higher rate.
- Other lender fees: origination and similar charges from section A of the Loan Estimate.
- Monthly mortgage insurance and how many years it lasts, if any.
How to read the results
Total cash out is upfront cost plus payments over the horizon. Net cost adds the balance still owed and subtracts the loan amount: what the loan has cost you by then if you paid it off. The lower net cost wins for that horizon. The crossover says how long you must keep the loan before paying points beats not paying them.
Worked example
On a $360,000, 30-year loan, Option A is 6.75% with no points and $1,500 of fees; Option B is 6.375% with 1.25 points ($4,500) and the same fees. Payments are $2,334.95 and $2,245.93. Over 7 years, Option A's net cost is $164,471 and Option B's is $159,473, a difference of $4,998. The points pay for themselves after about 40 months (3.3 years): sell or refinance sooner and Option A is cheaper.
Calculated with version us-2026.11-1.
Assumptions
Both options are fixed-rate, monthly, with interest at the rate ÷ 12. Points and fees are paid in cash at closing. Net cost ignores taxes, what your cash could earn elsewhere, and inflation.
Limitations
Real offers differ in more than price: rate lock length, prepayment rules, servicing and closing timelines. Use the APR on each Loan Estimate as a second check, and compare offers issued on the same day.
Related questions
Should I pay points? Only if you expect to keep the loan past the crossover. Read points and lender credits.
Why does the APR differ from the rate? See interest rate vs APR.
Calculations are estimates for general educational use. They are not financial, tax or legal advice, a loan offer, a rate quote or an approval. Actual rates, payments, insurance, taxes, fees and eligibility depend on the lender, the property, the program rules and your circumstances.
More calculators
- Mortgage paymentPrincipal and interest plus taxes, insurance, HOA and mortgage insurance.
- Closing costsLender, title, taxes, prepaids, escrow and the cash you bring.
- AffordabilityThe price your income and debts support, with adjustable limits.
- RefinancePayment change, break-even and cost over the same horizon.
- Extra paymentsMonthly, yearly and one-time extras, with interest saved.
- ARM resetPayments after each reset, with caps, floors and a higher-rate case.
